Games like Choice of the Pirate: what to play next?

In the same spirit

18 games in the spirit of Choice of the Pirate (2016): same vibe, same mechanics, picked by critics and players.

In the same spirit as Choice of the Pirate (18)

Heroes of Myth RPG by Choice of Games (2019) ★ 3.5 Vampire: The Masquerade - Parliament of Knives RPG by Choice of Games (2021) Champion of the Gods RPG by Choice of Games (2015) ★ 4 The Fog Knows Your Name RPG by Choice of Games (2019) ★ 3.5 Werewolf: The Apocalypse - The Book of Hungry Names RPG by Choice of Games (2024) Hunter: The Reckoning - The Beast of Glenkildove RPG by Choice of Games (2025) Heart of the House RPG by Choice of Games (2017) ★ 3.5 Tally Ho RPG by Choice of Games (2017) ★ 3.5 Choice of Rebels: Uprising RPG by Choice of Games (2017) ★ 4 Werewolves: Haven Rising RPG by Choice of Games (2018) ★ 3.5 Choice of Magics RPG by Choice of Games (2018) ★ 3.5 Choice of Alexandria RPG by Choice of Games (2016) ★ 3.5 Vampire: The Masquerade - Out for Blood RPG by Choice of Games (2021) Slammed! RPG by Choice of Games (2013) ★ 4from $6.99 Fields of Asphodel RPG by Hosted Games (2024) Heroes Rise: HeroFall RPG by Choice of Games LLC (2014) ★ 4 Choice of Robots RPG by Choice of Games LLC (2014) ★ 3.47 A Wise Use of Time RPG by Choice of Games (2015) ★ 4