In the same spirit

Games like Return to Mysterious Island: what to play next?

18 games in the spirit of Return to Mysterious Island (2004): same vibe, same mechanics, picked by critics and players.

In the same spirit as Return to Mysterious Island (18)

True Fear: Forsaken Souls Part 1 Adventure by Goblinz Studio (2016) ★ 4.24 True Fear: Forsaken Souls Part 2 Adventure by Goblinz Studio (2018) · ≈ 6h ★ 3.51 What Never Was Adventure by Acke Hallgren (2019) · ≈ 1h ★ 3.47 Monument Valley Adventure by ustwo games (2014) · ≈ 3h Metacritic 89★ 4.4 The Room 4: Old Sins Adventure by Fireproof Games (2018) · ≈ 4h Metacritic 86★ 4.37 Myst III: Exile Adventure by Presto Studios (2001) Metacritic 83★ 4.26 Myst IV: Revelation Adventure by Ubisoft Montreal (2004) Metacritic 82★ 4.06 Syberia Adventure by Microids (2002) · ≈ 11h Metacritic 82★ 3.94 Agent A: A puzzle in disguise Adventure by Yak & co (2015) · ≈ 5h Metacritic 80★ 4 Call of the Sea Adventure by Out of the Blue (2020) · ≈ 6h Metacritic 77★ 3.71 Myst V: End of Ages Strategy by Cyan Worlds (2005) Metacritic 80★ 3.44 Nancy Drew: Last Train to Blue Moon Canyon Adventure by Her Interactive (2005) Metacritic 77★ 3.51 Nancy Drew: Danger on Deception Island Adventure by Her Interactive (2003) Metacritic 81★ 3.01 Nancy Drew: Danger by Design Adventure by HeR Interactive (2006) · ≈ 6h Metacritic 70★ 3.81 The House of Da Vinci 3 RPG by Blue Brain Games (2022) ★ 3.22 Nancy Drew: Shadow at the Water's Edge Adventure by Her Interactive (2010) ★ 3.04 TRAUMA Adventure by Krystian Majewski (2011) · ≈ 1h Metacritic 62★ 2.32 Blue Prince Strategy by Dogubomb (2025) · ≈ 22h Metacritic 92★ 4.16