In the same spirit
Games like MLB The Show 23: what to play next?
18 games in the spirit of MLB The Show 23 (2023): same vibe, same mechanics, picked by critics and players.
Launch the machine with this filter →In the same spirit as MLB The Show 23 (18)
MLB The Show 26
Sports by SIE San Diego Studio (2026) · ≈ 32h
Critics 80/100★ 4
NBA 2K26
Sports by Visual Concepts (2025) · ≈ 79h
Critics 87/100★ 4.01
NBA 2K2
Sports by Visual Concepts (2001)
Critics 78/100★ 4.14
Elasto Mania
Action by Elasto Mania Team (2000)
★ 4.46
MLB 11: The Show
Sports by SCE San Diego Studio (2011)
Critics 86/100★ 4.32
Super Mega Baseball 4
Sports by Metalhead Software (2023)
Critics 86/100★ 4.28
EA Sports College Football 25
Sports by EA Orlando (2024)
Critics 86/100★ 4.23
EA Sports College Football 26
Sports by EA Orlando (2025) · ≈ 53h
Critics 87/100★ 4.15
World Soccer: Winning Eleven 7 International
Sports by Konami Computer Entertainment Tokyo (2003)
Critics 87/100★ 4.14
Madden NFL 11
Sports by EA Canada (2010)
Critics 86/100★ 4.15
NCAA Football 09
Sports by EA Canada (2008)
Critics 86/100★ 4.05
NCAA Football 11
Sports by EA Canada (2010)
Critics 86/100★ 3.91
FIFA Soccer 11
Sports by EA Canada (2010)
Critics 84/100★ 3.95
Tiger Woods PGA Tour 11
Sports by EA Orlando (2010)
Critics 85/100★ 3.86
Super Mega Baseball: Extra Innings
Sports by Metalhead Software (2015)
Critics 82/100★ 4.05
WWE 2K23
Action by Visual Concepts (2023)
Critics 84/100★ 3.87
Don Bradman Cricket 14
Sports by Big Ant Studios (2014)
★ 4.05
Super Mega Baseball 2
Sports by Metalhead Software (2018)
Metacritic 83★ 3.9