In the same spirit

Games like Pony Island: what to play next?

18 games in the spirit of Pony Island (2016): same vibe, same mechanics, picked by critics and players.

In the same spirit as Pony Island (18)

Detention Indie by RedCandleGames (2017) · ≈ 4h Metacritic 83★ 4.1 Inscryption Indie by Daniel Mullins Games (2021) · ≈ 8h Metacritic 86★ 4.38 INSIDE Adventure by Playdead (2016) · ≈ 4h Metacritic 87★ 4.38 Thimbleweed Park Indie by Terrible Toybox (2017) · ≈ 7h Metacritic 84★ 4.08 The Swapper Adventure by Curve Digital (2013) · ≈ 3h Metacritic 87★ 3.53 Deponia Indie by Daedalic Entertainment (2012) · ≈ 4h Metacritic 74★ 3.85 Her Story Indie by Sam Barlow (2015) · ≈ 4h Metacritic 88★ 3.98 Machinarium Family by Amanita Design (2009) · ≈ 3h Metacritic 85★ 4.18 Samorost 3 Adventure by Amanita Design (2016) · ≈ 4h Metacritic 80★ 4.19 Broken Age Adventure by Double Fine Productions (2014) · ≈ 5h Metacritic 81★ 3.65 Owlboy Indie by D-Pad Studio (2016) · ≈ 4h Metacritic 88★ 3.83 To the Moon Adventure by X.D. Network (2011) · ≈ 4h Metacritic 81★ 4.29 Orwell: Keeping an Eye On You Indie by Osmotic Studios (2016) · ≈ 3h Metacritic 77★ 3.28 Papers, Please Educational by Lucas Pope (2013) · ≈ 4h Metacritic 85★ 4.37 Oxenfree Indie by Night School Studio (2016) · ≈ 4h Metacritic 80★ 3.91 Sunless Sea Indie by Failbetter Games (2015) · ≈ 3h Metacritic 81★ 3.7 Beholder Indie by Alawar Entertainment (2016) · ≈ 4h Metacritic 75★ 3.8 Layers of Fear Indie by Bloober Team (2016) · ≈ 3h Metacritic 72★ 3.54