In the same spirit

Games like Mafia: The City of Lost Heaven: what to play next?

18 games in the spirit of Mafia: The City of Lost Heaven (2002): same vibe, same mechanics, picked by critics and players.

In the same spirit as Mafia: The City of Lost Heaven (18)

Grand Theft Auto III Shooter by DMA Design (2001) · ≈ 1h Metacritic 93★ 4.16 Shadow of the Tomb Raider Adventure by Eidos Montreal (2018) · ≈ 10h Metacritic 78★ 3.92 Prototype Casual by Activision (2009) · ≈ 3h Metacritic 79★ 3.8 Hell is Us Adventure by Rogue Factor (2025) · ≈ 5h ★ 3.5 Red Dead Redemption 2 Action by Rockstar Games (2018) · ≈ 21h Metacritic 96★ 4.59 God of War (2018) Action by Santa Monica Studio (2018) · ≈ 15h Metacritic 94★ 4.54 Resident Evil 4 Adventure by Capcom (2023) · ≈ 24h ★ 4.57 The Last of Us Part II Remastered Adventure by Naughty Dog (2024) · ≈ 33h ★ 4.5 Batman: Arkham City - Game of the Year Edition Adventure by Feral Interactive (2012) · ≈ 9h Metacritic 91★ 4.4 Batman: Arkham Asylum Game of the Year Edition Platformer by Feral Interactive (2010) · ≈ 8h Metacritic 91★ 4.39 The Elder Scrolls III: Morrowind Action by Bethesda Game Studios (2002) · ≈ 2h Metacritic 89★ 4.37 Legacy of Kain: Soul Reaver Platformer by Sony Interactive Entertainment (1999) · ≈ 1h Metacritic 91★ 4.08 Final Fantasy VII Rebirth Adventure by Square Enix (2024) · ≈ 71h ★ 4.33 Resident Evil 7: Biohazard Shooter by Capcom (2017) · ≈ 10h Metacritic 85★ 4.33 Black Myth: Wu Kong Adventure by Game Science (2024) · ≈ 24h ★ 4.27 Fable: The Lost Chapters Adventure by Lionhead Studios (2005) · ≈ 2h Metacritic 83★ 4.44 Prince of Persia: Warrior Within Adventure by Ubisoft (2004) · ≈ 2h Metacritic 83★ 4.4 Psychonauts Platformer by Double Fine Productions (2005) · ≈ 4h Metacritic 87★ 4.05